4 Steps to tell an Employee they are Not Ready for a Promotion with 3 examples
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Communicating to an employee that they are not yet ready for a promotion is a challenging task for managers. This situation requires finesse, empathy, and clarity to ensure the employee understands the decision while maintaining their motivation and commitment to growth within the organization. Let’s explore why this conversation is tricky and how managers can effectively handle it using the GROW framework, supported by practical examples.
Why Communicating Promotion Readiness is Tricky for Managers
Managing Expectations: Employees often have high expectations for career advancement, and not meeting these expectations can lead to disappointment and demotivation.
Balancing Feedback: Managers must provide constructive feedback on areas where the employee needs improvement without undermining their confidence or commitment.
Preserving Relationships: Promotion decisions can impact team dynamics and individual morale. Managers need to communicate openly while maintaining respect and professionalism.
Developmental Focus: The conversation should be focused on developmental opportunities and future growth rather than perceived shortcomings.
The GROW Model: A Framework for Managing Promotion Readiness Conversations
The GROW Model is a structured framework used in coaching and mentoring conversations to facilitate goal setting and development. It stands for:
Goal Setting: Establishing clear objectives and career aspirations.
Reality Checking: Assessing the current situation and performance objectively.
Options Generation: Exploring opportunities and actions for improvement.
Way Forward: Defining a plan of action with clear steps and timelines.
Step-by-Step Guide Using the GROW Model
1. Goal Setting (G)
Description: Begin by understanding the employee’s career goals and their aspirations for the promotion.
Example: "Sarah, I understand you’ve applied for the Team Lead position. Can you share with me what you hope to achieve in this role?"
2. Reality Checking (R)
Description: Provide specific feedback on the employee’s current skills and performance related to the promotion criteria.
Example: "Based on our recent projects, while your technical skills are strong, we've noticed opportunities for growth in your ability to delegate tasks effectively and provide strategic direction."
3. Options Generation (O)
Description: Collaborate with the employee to identify development opportunities and actions they can take to enhance their readiness.
Example: "To further develop your leadership capabilities, we could enroll you in a leadership development program or assign you to lead a cross-functional project to gain more experience."
4. Way Forward (W)
Description: Agree on a plan of action with specific steps, timelines, and milestones for improvement.
Example: "Let's outline a development plan over the next six months that includes attending leadership workshops, seeking mentorship from senior leaders, and taking on additional responsibilities. We'll review your progress monthly to ensure you're on track."
Practical Examples Using the GROW Framework
Example 1: Goal Setting
Manager: "John, I understand you’re interested in the Senior Analyst position. What are your career goals and how do you see this role fitting into your long-term aspirations?"
Example 2: Reality Checking
Manager: "Based on our review of your performance and feedback from the team, we've identified areas where further development is needed to align with the expectations of the Senior Analyst role."
Example 3: Options Generation
Manager: "To enhance your candidacy for future opportunities, we could explore additional training in data analysis techniques and project management. How do you feel about pursuing these options?"
Sample Dialogue
Manager (M): Hi Emma, thanks for taking the time to meet with me today. I wanted to have a conversation about your recent application for the Project Manager position.
Employee (E): Hi, [Manager's Name]. Sure, I was hoping to hear some feedback.
M: Absolutely. First, I want to acknowledge your enthusiasm and dedication to your work. Your commitment to the team has been evident, and we value your contributions.
E: Thank you, that means a lot to me.
M: I want to discuss the promotion to Project Manager. We've carefully reviewed your performance and potential for this role. While your technical skills and attention to detail are strong, we've identified a few areas where additional growth is needed.
E: Okay, I understand. Could you elaborate on those areas?
M: Certainly. One aspect we've noticed is the need for further development in leading cross-functional teams. While you excel in your individual contributions, leading a team requires a broader strategic approach and the ability to navigate complex dynamics.
E: I see. Are there specific instances that stood out?
M: For example, in the recent XYZ project, there were moments where clearer delegation and alignment with team members could have streamlined our progress. Developing stronger interpersonal skills and fostering collaboration across departments will be key.
E: I appreciate your honesty. What steps do you recommend I take to improve in these areas?
M: I'm glad you're open to discussing this. One option could be to seek mentorship from senior project managers who can provide guidance on leadership strategies. Additionally, there are leadership development workshops coming up that could enhance your skills in team management and communication.
E: That sounds like a good plan. I'm committed to improving in these areas. How can we move forward from here?
M: Let's outline a development plan together. We can schedule regular check-ins to monitor your progress and adjust as needed. I believe with focused effort and support, you can strengthen your candidacy for future opportunities.
E: Thank you, [Manager's Name]. I appreciate your guidance and confidence in my potential. I'm looking forward to working on these areas.
M: You're welcome, Emma. I believe in your ability to grow into this role with dedication and continued development. Let's set up a follow-up meeting next week to finalize your development plan.
Conclusion
Navigating a conversation where you tell an employee they are not ready for a promotion requires sensitivity and a focus on development rather than disappointment. By using the GROW Model—setting clear goals, providing constructive feedback, exploring development options, and defining a way forward—managers can effectively guide employees toward growth opportunities while maintaining their motivation and commitment to the organization's success.
This approach not only supports individual development but also fosters a culture of continuous improvement and transparency within the workplace. Ultimately, it enables managers to navigate promotion readiness conversations with empathy and clarity, ensuring that employees feel valued and supported in their professional growth journey.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
