How Managers Can Resolve Conflicts with Employees
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Conflicts between managers and employees are notoriously tricky situations that can significantly impact workplace dynamics and productivity. These challenges arise from various factors:
Power imbalances often hinder open communication.
Emotional involvement can cloud rational decision-making.
Differing perspectives between managers and employees can create misunderstandings.
Conflicts can affect team morale and overall performance.
Managers must balance individual needs with organizational goals.
Time constraints in busy work environments can complicate thorough resolution.
Many managers lack specific training in conflict resolution.
Personal biases can interfere with finding mutually beneficial solutions.
Potential legal implications add complexity to the process.
The long-term consequences of conflict resolution can impact workplace relationships and culture.
Given these challenges, managers need a structured approach to navigate and resolve conflicts effectively. This is where the SMART framework can be invaluable.
What is the SMART Framework
SMART is an acronym that stands for Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. Originally developed for goal-setting, this framework can be adapted to conflict resolution, providing a systematic approach to addressing and solving workplace disputes.
Why is SMART Appropriate for Conflict Resolution
The SMART framework is well-suited for conflict resolution because it:
Provides a clear structure for addressing complex issues.
Encourages objective analysis rather than emotional reactions.
Promotes specific, actionable solutions.
Ensures that resolutions are realistic and achievable.
Aligns conflict resolution with broader organizational goals.
Sets clear timelines for implementation and follow-up.
How to Use SMART for Conflict Resolution
Let's break down how managers can apply each element of SMART to resolve conflicts with employees:
Specific:
Clearly identify the exact nature of the conflict.
Articulate the issues from both the manager's and employee's perspectives.
Define what a successful resolution would look like for all parties involved.
Example: Instead of addressing a vague "communication problem," specify that "weekly project updates are inconsistent and often late."
Measurable:
Determine how progress and success will be measured.
Establish concrete criteria for evaluating the resolution.
Example: "Project updates will be considered timely if submitted by 5 PM every Friday."
Achievable:
Ensure that the proposed solutions are realistic and within the capabilities of both parties.
Consider available resources and potential obstacles.
Example: If the employee struggles with time management, provide tools or training to help them meet deadlines.
Relevant:
Align the conflict resolution with broader team and organizational goals.
Ensure that addressing this conflict will positively impact the work environment.
Example: Demonstrate how improved communication through timely updates will enhance overall team productivity.
Time-bound:
Set a clear timeline for implementing solutions and reviewing progress.
Establish checkpoints to assess the effectiveness of the resolution.
Example: "We'll implement this new update system for one month, then review its effectiveness on [specific date]."
Implementing SMART Conflict Resolution
Schedule a private meeting with the employee to discuss the conflict.
Use the SMART framework to guide your conversation and solution-finding process.
Collaboratively develop a SMART action plan to address the conflict.
Document the agreed-upon plan and share it with the employee.
Follow up according to the established timeline and adjust as necessary.
Sample Dialogue
Manager: "Hi Sarah, thanks for meeting with me. I've noticed some tension lately, and I'd like us to discuss it openly and find a solution together. Is that okay with you?"
Sarah (Employee): "Yes, I appreciate that. I've been feeling frustrated lately."
Manager: "I'm glad you're willing to talk about it. Let's try to address this systematically. Can you tell me specifically what's been bothering you?"
Sarah: "Well, I feel like my ideas are often overlooked in team meetings, and I'm not getting credit for my contributions to projects."
Manager: "I see. Thank you for being specific. Let's break this down using a structured approach. First, let's be specific about the issue. You feel your ideas are overlooked and you're not receiving proper credit. Is that correct?"
Sarah: "Yes, that's right."
Manager: "Okay. Now, let's think about how we can measure improvement in this area. What would success look like to you?"
Sarah: "I guess if I could present at least one idea in each team meeting and have it seriously considered, and if my name was included in project credits when I've made significant contributions."
Manager: "Those are good, measurable goals. Now, let's consider if they're achievable. I believe they are, but we might need to make some changes to our meeting structure and project documentation process. What do you think?"
Sarah: "Yes, I think that's achievable. It doesn't seem unreasonable."
Manager: "Great. Now, let's talk about relevance. How do you think these changes would impact your work and the team's performance?"
Sarah: "I think I'd feel more motivated and engaged. It might also bring more diverse ideas to our projects, which could improve our outcomes."
Manager: "I agree. That aligns well with our team goals of innovation and employee engagement. Now, let's set a timeframe. How about we implement these changes over the next month and then review the results?"
Sarah: "That sounds good to me."
Manager: "Excellent. So, to summarize our SMART plan:
Specific: Ensure your ideas are heard in meetings and you receive credit for project contributions.
Measurable: You'll present at least one idea per team meeting, and your name will be included in project credits when appropriate.
Achievable: We'll adjust our meeting structure and project documentation process to facilitate this.
Relevant: This will increase your engagement and potentially improve team innovation.
Time-bound: We'll implement these changes over the next month and review the results on [specific date].
Does this sound like a plan that addresses your concerns?"
Sarah: "Yes, it does. Thank you for taking the time to discuss this and come up with a concrete plan."
Manager: "You're welcome, Sarah. I appreciate your openness in discussing this. Let's schedule a follow-up meeting for [date] to review how these changes are working. In the meantime, please don't hesitate to come to me if you have any concerns or suggestions."
Sarah: "I will, thank you."
Conclusion
By applying the SMART framework to conflict resolution, managers can transform a potentially volatile situation into a structured, solution-oriented process. This approach not only addresses immediate issues but also builds a foundation for improved communication and understanding in the long term.
Remember, successful conflict resolution isn't just about solving the current problem—it's about fostering a work environment where open dialogue and collaborative problem-solving become the norm. By using the SMART framework, managers can lead by example, demonstrating a commitment to fair, effective, and constructive conflict resolution.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
