How to Break Through to an Employee in Denial After a Poor Performance Review
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Handling an employee in denial after a poor performance review is a complex and delicate task for managers. Several factors contribute to the difficulty of this situation:
Emotional Responses: Performance reviews can evoke strong emotional reactions, especially if the feedback is critical or unexpected. Employees in denial may feel hurt, embarrassed, or defensive, making it challenging for them to acknowledge their shortcomings.
Threat to Self-Image: Negative feedback can threaten an employee's self-image and professional identity. Denial often acts as a defense mechanism to protect against feelings of failure or inadequacy, hindering their ability to accept and address performance issues.
Communication Barriers: Denial creates barriers to effective communication. Employees may dismiss or minimize feedback, leading to misunderstandings and preventing constructive dialogue about areas for improvement.
Resistance to Change: Employees in denial may resist acknowledging the need for change, fearing the consequences or feeling overwhelmed by the prospect of addressing performance deficiencies.
Impact on Team Dynamics: Persistent denial can impact team dynamics, morale, and productivity. It may create tension within the team if performance issues affect collaborative efforts or project outcomes.
Managerial Challenges: Managers must navigate the delicate balance of providing honest feedback while maintaining empathy and respect for the employee's feelings. Poorly managed conversations can escalate defensiveness and strain the manager-employee relationship.
Given these challenges, managers must approach breaking through to an employee in denial with empathy, patience, and a strategic framework that fosters constructive dialogue and promotes growth.
Breaking Through to an Employee in Denial After a Poor Performance Review Using the GROW Framework
Managers can effectively navigate the complexities of addressing denial after a poor performance review by utilizing the GROW framework. This model provides a structured approach to coaching and guiding employees towards recognizing their challenges, committing to improvement, and achieving their full potential.
What is the GROW Framework
The GROW framework is a widely-used coaching model that stands for:
G - Goal: Define a clear goal or objective for the conversation. In the context of a performance review, the goal might be to help the employee understand the feedback received, acknowledge areas for improvement, and commit to specific actions for growth.
R - Reality: Encourage the employee to objectively assess their current reality. Provide specific examples and feedback from the performance review to highlight areas of concern or underperformance. This step is crucial for overcoming denial by grounding the discussion in factual observations.
O - Options: Explore potential options and strategies for improvement together. Involve the employee in brainstorming ideas on how they can address the identified issues and achieve their goals. This fosters ownership and empowers the employee to take an active role in their development.
W - Way Forward: Agree on a concrete action plan with specific steps and timelines. Define roles, responsibilities, and resources needed to support the employee in implementing the agreed-upon actions. The plan should be realistic, achievable, and aligned with the employee's developmental needs.
Why is the GROW Framework Appropriate for Handling Denial
Structured Approach: The GROW model provides a systematic and structured approach to coaching conversations. It helps managers organize their thoughts and feedback coherently, ensuring that all critical aspects, from goal setting to action planning, are addressed comprehensively.
Focus on Reality: The framework encourages a reality-based assessment of performance issues. By using specific examples and feedback, managers can help employees confront and accept their areas of challenge, reducing defensiveness and facilitating a more open dialogue.
Empowerment and Ownership: GROW promotes employee empowerment and ownership of their development. By involving employees in exploring options and setting goals, managers foster commitment and motivation for change, which are essential for overcoming denial.
Clear Path Forward: The final step of defining a way forward ensures clarity and accountability. It sets clear expectations for both the employee and the manager, ensuring that progress is monitored, support is provided, and adjustments are made as needed.
How to Use the GROW Framework in Practice - Sample Dialogue
Manager (Alex): Hi Sarah, I'd like to discuss your recent performance review. One of the areas we need to address is your project deadlines being missed.
Sarah: I don't think it's as big of an issue as you're making it out to be. Sometimes things just don't go as planned.
Goal (G): Alex sets the goal for the conversation to help Sarah understand the impact of missed deadlines, acknowledge the need for improvement in time management, and commit to specific actions.
Reality (R): Alex provides specific examples of missed deadlines and explains how it has affected team projects and timelines.
Options (O): Together, Alex and Sarah brainstorm strategies to improve time management, such as prioritizing tasks, setting realistic deadlines, and improving communication about project progress.
Way Forward (W): They agree on a plan where Sarah will implement these strategies and Alex will provide support through regular check-ins to monitor progress and provide guidance.
In this example, Alex effectively utilizes the GROW framework to guide the conversation with Sarah, addressing her denial by focusing on reality-based assessments and collaborative problem-solving. By using this structured approach, managers can facilitate productive discussions, foster employee growth, and ultimately improve team performance and morale.
Conclusion
By employing the GROW framework, managers can navigate the complexities of handling denial after a poor performance review with clarity, empathy, and a focus on fostering constructive change. This approach not only helps in addressing immediate performance issues but also cultivates a culture of continuous improvement and professional development within the organization.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
