How to Coach Employees Who Don't Follow Through on Commitments
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Dealing with employees who consistently fail to follow through on commitments can be a daunting challenge for managers. This situation is tricky for several reasons:
Trust and Accountability: When employees repeatedly fail to fulfill their commitments, it can erode trust within the team and undermine accountability. This can lead to frustration among team members and hinder overall team performance.
Communication Breakdowns: Miscommunication or misunderstandings about expectations and deadlines can contribute to employees not following through on commitments. Managers must ensure clear and open communication to mitigate these issues effectively.
Motivation and Engagement: Low levels of motivation or disengagement can also be contributing factors. Employees who lack motivation may struggle to prioritize tasks and meet deadlines, leading to a pattern of missed commitments.
Root Causes: There may be underlying reasons why employees struggle to follow through on commitments, such as poor time management skills, lack of clarity about expectations, or competing priorities. Identifying and addressing these root causes requires insight and sensitivity from managers.
Given these challenges, managers need a structured framework to effectively coach employees who don't follow through on commitments. One such framework that is particularly effective in this situation is the GROW model.
Introducing the GROW Framework
The GROW framework is a widely-used coaching model that helps managers guide employees through problem-solving and goal-setting processes. GROW stands for:
Goal: Establish a clear goal with the employee. Identify the specific commitment or task they are struggling to follow through on and why it's important to achieve it. Setting a clear and achievable goal provides focus and direction for the coaching process.
Reality: Explore the current reality or situation surrounding the employee's inability to follow through on commitments. This involves identifying any obstacles, challenges, or underlying issues that may be contributing to the problem. Encourage open and honest communication to gain a comprehensive understanding of the situation.
Options: Brainstorm potential options or strategies for overcoming the obstacles identified in the reality phase. Encourage the employee to generate multiple ideas and consider different approaches to address the problem. Explore both short-term and long-term solutions, as well as any potential barriers or risks associated with each option.
Way Forward: Establish a concrete plan of action for moving forward. Help the employee select the most feasible and effective option and outline specific steps and timelines for implementation. Ensure the plan is realistic, achievable, and aligned with the employee's goals and capabilities.
Why is the GROW framework appropriate
The GROW framework is particularly well-suited for coaching employees who struggle to follow through on commitments for several reasons:
Structured Approach: The GROW model provides a structured and systematic approach to coaching, which helps managers guide employees through the problem-solving process in a clear and organized manner.
Focus on Goal Setting: By starting with a clear goal, the GROW framework provides direction and motivation for the coaching process. This helps employees understand the importance of following through on commitments and sets the stage for effective problem-solving.
Reality Exploration: The GROW model encourages managers and employees to explore the underlying reasons for the commitment challenges in a non-judgmental and objective manner. This helps identify potential obstacles and barriers that may be hindering progress.
Option Generation: Through brainstorming potential options and strategies, the GROW framework empowers employees to take ownership of finding solutions to their commitment challenges. This fosters a sense of autonomy and accountability, which can increase motivation and engagement.
Action Planning: By establishing a concrete plan of action for moving forward, the GROW framework helps ensure that the coaching process leads to tangible results. This involves identifying specific steps, timelines, and resources needed to address the commitment challenges effectively.
How to Use the GROW Framework
Set the Goal: Begin by establishing a clear goal with the employee. Clearly define the commitment or task they are struggling with and why it's important to address it.
Explore the Reality: Encourage open and honest communication to explore the current reality surrounding the commitment challenges. Identify any obstacles, challenges, or underlying issues that may be contributing to the problem.
Generate Options: Brainstorm potential options or strategies for overcoming the obstacles identified in the reality phase. Encourage the employee to consider different approaches and explore both short-term and long-term solutions.
Establish the Way Forward: Help the employee select the most feasible and effective option and develop a concrete plan of action for moving forward. Outline specific steps, timelines, and resources needed to address the commitment challenges effectively.
Sample Dialogue
MANAGER: Hi [Employee], can we have a quick chat?
EMPLOYEE: Sure, [Manager]. What's up?
MANAGER: I wanted to talk to you about something important. Lately, I've noticed that there have been a few instances where deadlines or commitments haven't been met. I understand that sometimes unexpected things come up, but it's important for us to address this so we can ensure the success of our team and projects.
EMPLOYEE: I appreciate you bringing this up, [Manager]. I know I haven't been as reliable as I should be, and I apologize for that.
MANAGRER: I understand, and I appreciate your honesty. I want to work with you to identify any obstacles or challenges that may be getting in the way of meeting your commitments. Can you tell me more about what's been going on?
EMPLOYEE: Well, I've been feeling overwhelmed with my workload lately, and I've been struggling to prioritize tasks effectively. I also haven't been communicating as well with my team members as I should be, which has led to some misunderstandings.
MANAGER: Thank you for sharing that with me. It's important for us to address these issues so we can find solutions together. Let's start by setting a clear goal for what we want to achieve moving forward. How about we work on improving your time management and communication skills?
EMPLOYEE: That sounds like a good place to start. I definitely need to work on those areas.
MANAGER: Great. Now, let's explore the current reality surrounding these challenges. What specific obstacles or challenges do you face when it comes to managing your workload and communicating effectively with your team?
EMPLOYEE: Well, I often feel like I have too much on my plate and struggle to prioritize tasks. And when it comes to communication, I sometimes find it difficult to express my needs and concerns to my team members.
MANAGER: I see. Let's brainstorm some potential options or strategies for overcoming these obstacles. What are some ways we can improve your time management skills and enhance communication with your team members?
EMPLOYEE: Maybe I could start by breaking down my tasks into smaller, more manageable chunks and setting realistic deadlines for myself. And for communication, I could make an effort to check in with my team more frequently and be more proactive about sharing updates and asking for help when needed.
MANAGER: Those are great ideas. Let's establish a concrete plan of action for moving forward. How about you start by implementing these strategies over the next few weeks and we can check in regularly to monitor your progress and make any necessary adjustments?
EMPLOYEE: That sounds like a plan. Thank you for your support and guidance, [Manager]. I'm committed to making positive changes and becoming more reliable in meeting my commitments.
MANAGER: I believe in you, [Employee]. Together, we can overcome these challenges and help you reach your full potential. Let's work together to ensure your success.
EMPLOYEE: Absolutely. Thank you, [Manager].
Conclusion
By using the GROW framework to coach employees who don't follow through on commitments, managers can empower employees to take ownership of their performance and overcome obstacles more effectively. This structured approach helps foster trust, accountability, and communication within the team, leading to improved performance and success.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
