How to Overcome Resistance to Hybrid Work: A Manager's Guide
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
As the world slowly returns to a new normal, many organizations are adopting hybrid work arrangements, combining the benefits of remote work with the advantages of in-office collaboration. However, convincing fully remote employees to return to the office, even part-time, can be a daunting task for managers.
The Challenge
Remote work has become the norm for many, and the thought of commuting to the office can be daunting. Employees may feel that returning to the office will disrupt their routine, reduce their flexibility, and increase distractions. Moreover, they may have grown accustomed to the comfort and autonomy of working from home, making it difficult to adjust to a traditional office environment.
Introducing ADKAR
So, how can managers overcome this resistance and successfully implement hybrid work arrangements? The answer lies in the ADKAR model, a change management framework developed by Prosci. ADKAR stands for Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, and Reinforcement, and it provides a structured approach to managing change and transitioning individuals through the process.
Why ADKAR?
ADKAR is particularly well-suited for managing resistance to hybrid work requirements because it:
Acknowledges the emotional and psychological aspects of change
Provides a clear, step-by-step approach to managing transition
Focuses on individual change, rather than organizational change
Using ADKAR
To use the ADKAR model, managers can follow these steps:
Awareness
Communicate the reasons behind the hybrid work arrangement
Explain the benefits and address concerns
Desire
Engage employees in the process
Encourage participation and feedback
Address fears and misconceptions
Knowledge
Provide training and resources
Equip employees with the skills needed for success in a hybrid work environment
Ability
Offer support and guidance
Help employees develop the skills and confidence needed to adapt
Reinforcement
Celebrate successes and progress
Continuously evaluate and improve the hybrid work arrangement
By using the ADKAR model, managers can effectively manage resistance to hybrid work requirements, support employees through the transition, and foster a positive and productive work environment.
Sample Dialogue: Manager and Employee Discussion
MANAGER: Hi, John. I wanted to touch base with you about our new hybrid work arrangement. I know you've been working remotely for a while, and I understand you might have some concerns about returning to the office.
EMPLOYEE (JOHN): Yeah, I'm not sure I want to go back to the office. I've gotten used to working from home, and I feel more productive.
MANAGER: I understand. That's a great point. Let's start with Awareness. Can I share some reasons why we're adopting this new hybrid model?
JOHN: Sure.
MANAGER: We want to encourage more collaboration and innovation among teams, and we believe this model will help us achieve that. We'll also have dedicated focus time for individual work.
JOHN: I see. That makes sense, but I'm still worried about the commute and distractions in the office.
MANAGER: I understand your concerns. Let's move to Desire. What would make you more comfortable with the idea of returning to the office?
JOHN: If I could have a flexible schedule and work from home one day a week, that would help.
MANAGER: That's something we can definitely discuss. Now, let's talk about Knowledge. What skills or resources do you need to feel confident working in a hybrid environment?
JOHN: I'm not sure. Maybe some training on how to prioritize tasks in a more distracting environment?
MANAGER: Absolutely. We can provide that. Moving to Ability, how can I support you in developing the skills you need to succeed in this new environment?
JOHN: Just being available to answer questions and provide feedback would be great.
MANAGER: Of course. Finally, let's talk about Reinforcement. How will we measure success and celebrate progress in this new hybrid model?
JOHN: That's a good point. Maybe regular check-ins to discuss how it's going and make adjustments as needed?
Manager: Exactly. I'm glad we had this conversation, John. Let's work together to make this transition successful.
In this dialogue, the manager:
Acknowledges John's concerns and addresses them directly
Explains the reasons behind the hybrid work arrangement (Awareness)
Encourages John to share his desires and concerns (Desire)
Identifies knowledge and skill gaps (Knowledge)
Offers support and resources (Ability)
Establishes a plan for reinforcement and evaluation (Reinforcement)
By using the ADKAR model, the manager is able to effectively address John's resistance and work together towards a successful transition.
Conclusion
Implementing hybrid work arrangements can be challenging, but with the ADKAR model, managers can overcome resistance and ensure a successful transition. By acknowledging the emotional and psychological aspects of change and providing a structured approach to managing transition, managers can create a work environment that balances business needs with employee well-being. Embrace the ADKAR model and lead your team through the change with confidence.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
