How to Rebuild Trust with a Disappointed or Disillusioned Employee After a Poor Performance Review

Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.

Rebuilding trust with an employee who feels disappointed or disillusioned after a poor performance review is a delicate and challenging task for managers. Here are several reasons why this situation can be particularly tricky:

1. Emotional Impact: Performance reviews often evoke strong emotions such as frustration, hurt, or anger, especially if the feedback is perceived as unfair or unjustified. These emotions can create barriers to effective communication and collaboration.

2. Perception of Fairness: Employees may question the fairness of the performance evaluation process or the validity of the feedback provided. This perception of unfairness can erode trust in management and the organization's commitment to employee development.

3. Communication Breakdown: Poor communication during the performance review or feedback session can contribute to misunderstandings and further strain the relationship. It's crucial for managers to address these communication gaps to rebuild trust effectively.

4. Motivational Impact: Disappointed employees may experience a decrease in motivation and engagement, affecting their performance and overall contribution to the team. Rebuilding trust is essential to re-engage employees and regain their commitment.

5. Personal and Professional Identity: A negative performance review can shake an employee's confidence in their abilities and professional identity. Managers must restore this confidence by demonstrating support and belief in the employee's potential.

6. Organizational Culture: The way managers handle performance reviews and feedback impacts the overall organizational culture. Employees who feel disillusioned may influence team morale and perceptions of leadership credibility.

Given these complexities, managers need a structured approach to navigate through the challenges and rebuild trust effectively.

Using the Trust Repair Framework to Rebuild Trust

One of the most effective frameworks for rebuilding trust with a disappointed or disillusioned employee is the Trust Repair Framework. This framework provides a systematic approach to address the breakdown in trust and foster a positive and productive working relationship. Here’s why it's appropriate for this situation and how to use it.

Trust Repair Framework

1. Acknowledge and Validate Feelings

• Why it's appropriate: Acknowledging and validating the employee's feelings demonstrates empathy and understanding. It opens up communication by showing that their emotions are recognized and respected.

• How to use it: Start the conversation by acknowledging the employee's feelings directly. For example, "I understand that the performance review was challenging for you, and I recognize how it may have affected your morale."

2. Review and Clarify Expectations

• Why it's appropriate: Clear communication is essential to rebuild trust. Reviewing and clarifying expectations ensures mutual understanding of performance standards, feedback mechanisms, and support available from management.

• How to use it: Discuss specific expectations that may not have been clear or were misunderstood during the performance review. Ensure the employee knows what is expected of them and how management will support their improvement.

3. Take Responsibility and Apologize (if necessary)

• Why it's appropriate: If there were shortcomings or misunderstandings during the performance review process, taking responsibility and apologizing can demonstrate humility and a commitment to resolving issues.

• How to use it: If appropriate, acknowledge any mistakes or miscommunications that may have contributed to the employee's disappointment. For example, "I apologize if there were misunderstandings in how your performance was evaluated. We could have communicated better about your progress."

4. Commit to Action and Follow Through

• Why it's appropriate: Actions speak louder than words in rebuilding trust. Committing to specific actions and following through on promises shows integrity and builds confidence that the relationship can be repaired.

• How to use it: Outline concrete steps and timelines for supporting the employee's development and addressing concerns raised during the review. Regularly check in to provide feedback and evaluate progress.

5. Rebuild and Reinforce

• Why it's appropriate: Trust is rebuilt through consistent positive interactions and supportive behaviors over time. Managers should reinforce trust-building efforts and maintain open lines of communication to prevent future misunderstandings.

• How to use it: Continuously demonstrate reliability, transparency, and fairness in all interactions with the employee. Celebrate successes and milestones achieved together, reinforcing the positive trajectory of the relationship.

Sample Dialogue

Manager: "Sarah, I want to discuss your recent performance review. I understand you were disappointed, and I want to address that. Your feedback is important to me, and I want us to move forward positively. First, I acknowledge how you feel and respect that."

Sarah: "Thank you. I appreciate that acknowledgment."

Manager: "Let’s review the expectations we have for your role and how we can clarify them moving forward. I want to ensure you know what’s expected and how we can support you better."

Sarah: "That would be helpful. Clear expectations would definitely make a difference."

Manager: "I also want to apologize if there were any misunderstandings during the review process. It's important to me that our communication is clear and supportive."

Sarah: "I appreciate that apology. Thank you."

Manager: "Moving forward, I’m committed to setting up regular check-ins to discuss your progress and provide any necessary support. I want to see you succeed and feel confident in your role."

Sarah: "That means a lot. I’m ready to work on rebuilding that trust."

In this scenario, the Trust Repair Framework guides the manager through acknowledging Sarah's feelings, clarifying expectations, taking responsibility (if necessary), committing to action, and reinforcing positive interactions. This structured approach helps rebuild trust by addressing concerns directly and demonstrating a genuine commitment to supporting Sarah's growth and success within the organization.

By implementing these steps thoughtfully and consistently, managers can navigate through the complexities of rebuilding trust after a disappointing performance review and foster a more positive and productive work environment.

Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.