The 4-Step Reframe: How to Turn Harsh Feedback to Helpful
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
As a leader, you know that feedback is essential to help your team grow and improve. But all too often, feedback comes across as criticism, leading to defensiveness and hurt feelings. What if you could transform your feedback into a powerful tool for growth and development?
Step 1: Shift from Judgment to Observation
Instead of saying "You're not meeting your sales targets, you need to work harder," say "I've noticed a dip in your sales numbers. Can we discuss strategies to help you get back on track?" Reframe your feedback to focus on specific behaviors or results, rather than making judgments or attacks.
Step 2: Focus on the Issue, Not the Person
When a team member is struggling with a project due to limited resources, instead of saying "I know the budget is tight, but we need to find a way to make it work," say "Let's brainstorm ways to prioritize resources and make the most of what we have." Separate the issue from the person and work together to find solutions.
Step 3: Use Specific Examples and Data
When a team member is having trouble with a specific task, instead of saying "You're not good at this," say "I've noticed you're struggling with this task. Let's break it down together and find a solution." Use specific examples and data to support your feedback and make it more actionable.
Step 4: Emphasize Growth and Development
If a team member is consistently late to meetings, instead of saying "You're always late, it's really frustrating," say "I've noticed you've been running behind schedule lately. Can we find a way to get you the support you need to arrive on time?" Focus on growth and development, rather than criticism or punishment.
More Examples of Harsh vs. Helpful Feedback
Sales:
Harsh: "You're not meeting your sales targets, you're not cut out for this job."
Helpful: "I've noticed a dip in your sales numbers. What strategies are you thinking of trying to get back on track?"
Customer Support:
Harsh: "You're not handling customer complaints well, you need to be more empathetic."
Helpful: "I've noticed some customers are feeling frustrated with our response times. What ideas do you have for improving our response times or empathizing with customers?"
Engineering:
Harsh: "Your code is sloppy, you need to be more careful."
Helpful: "I've noticed some errors in the code. Have you considered trying a different approach or seeking input from a colleague?"
Marketing:
Harsh: "Your marketing campaigns are not effective, you're not creative enough."
Helpful: "I've noticed our marketing metrics are not improving. What ideas do you have for refreshing our strategy or trying new tactics?"
Product Management:
Harsh: "Your product roadmap is not aligned with our company goals, you're not strategic enough."
Helpful: "I've noticed some misalignment between our product roadmap and company goals. How do you propose we prioritize features to better align with business outcomes?"
By reframing your feedback from harsh to helpful, you can create a culture of growth and development, where your team feels empowered to take risks and improve. Remember, feedback is a powerful tool – let's use it to empower each other.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
