What should you Not Say to an Employee during a Performance Review
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Navigating what not to say during a performance review is a delicate task for managers due to several reasons:
Emotional Impact: Performance reviews are inherently emotional for both managers and employees. Negative or poorly delivered feedback can evoke strong emotional reactions such as defensiveness, disappointment, or even resentment. It's crucial for managers to handle feedback with sensitivity to maintain morale and motivation.
Impact on Relationships: The way feedback is delivered during a performance review can significantly impact the relationship between the manager and the employee. Poorly chosen words or insensitive remarks can damage trust and respect, leading to strained relationships and decreased productivity.
Legal and HR Considerations: Certain statements made during performance reviews can have legal implications if they are perceived as discriminatory, biased, or not aligned with organizational policies. Managers need to be aware of these implications to avoid potential legal issues.
Communication Effectiveness: Effective communication is key to delivering constructive feedback. Managers must ensure that their feedback is clear, specific, and actionable. Vague or ambiguous comments can confuse the employee and hinder their ability to understand what needs improvement.
Developmental Impact: The primary goal of a performance review is to facilitate employee development and improvement. Feedback that is not constructive or focused on personal attacks rather than performance can hinder this goal and demotivate employees.
Given these challenges, having a structured framework to guide what not to say during a performance review is essential for managers to navigate this delicate process effectively.
Using the CLEAR Framework to Know What Not to Say During a Performance Review
The CLEAR framework provides a structured approach for managers to determine what not to say during a performance review, ensuring that feedback is constructive, fair, and respectful. Here’s how managers can utilize this framework effectively:
What is the CLEAR Framework
The CLEAR framework is designed to guide managers in delivering effective feedback during performance reviews:
C - Constructive: Ensure that feedback is focused on behaviors or outcomes that can be improved. Avoid vague or generalized criticisms that do not offer specific guidance for improvement.
L - Legal and Fair: Adhere to legal and organizational guidelines to avoid discriminatory or biased remarks. Feedback should be based on objective criteria related to job performance.
E - Empathetic: Approach the performance review with empathy and understanding. Acknowledge the employee's perspective and emotions, and deliver feedback in a supportive manner.
A - Actionable: Provide feedback that is actionable and clear. Outline specific steps or behaviors that the employee can take to address areas needing improvement.
R - Respectful: Maintain a respectful tone throughout the performance review. Avoid derogatory or demeaning language that could damage the employee's self-esteem or morale.
Why is the CLEAR Framework Appropriate
The CLEAR framework is particularly suitable for performance reviews because it:
Promotes Clarity: Helps managers communicate feedback clearly and effectively, reducing misunderstandings and ambiguity.
Ensures Fairness: Ensures that feedback is fair and objective, aligned with legal and organizational standards.
Fosters Empathy: Encourages managers to consider the employee's perspective and emotions, fostering a supportive and understanding environment.
Encourages Action: Provides actionable steps for improvement, enabling employees to make meaningful progress in their performance.
How to Use the CLEAR Framework in Practice
1. Constructive Feedback
Example: Instead of saying "Your work is sloppy," say "I've noticed some errors in your recent reports. Let's discuss how we can improve accuracy by implementing a proofreading process."
2. Legal and Fair
Example: Avoid comments related to age, race, gender, or other protected characteristics. Focus on job-related performance criteria.
3. Empathetic Approach
Example: Acknowledge the employee's efforts and challenges. For instance, "I understand you've had a lot on your plate lately. Let's work together to prioritize tasks more effectively."
4. Actionable Feedback
Example: Instead of saying "You need to communicate better," say "Let's set a goal to improve communication by scheduling regular team meetings and ensuring everyone is informed of project updates."
5. Respectful Communication
Example: Avoid language that undermines the employee's dignity or professionalism. Maintain a respectful tone throughout the discussion.
Sample Dialogue
Manager (Mark): Hi Emma, thank you for meeting with me today. I wanted to discuss your performance over the past quarter.
Employee (Emma): Of course, Mark. I'm interested to hear your feedback.
Mark: Great. Let's start by acknowledging some of the positive aspects of your work. Your attention to detail and creativity in the recent project were impressive. You've contributed some valuable ideas that have positively impacted our team's approach.
Emma: Thank you, Mark. I appreciate the recognition.
Mark: Now, let's address an area where we can focus on improvement. I've noticed there have been a few instances where deadlines were missed, which impacted our team's progress. Can you share your perspective on what might have caused these delays?
Emma: I agree, there were a couple of deadlines I missed due to unexpected issues that came up. I apologize for the delays.
Mark: I understand, and I appreciate your honesty. Moving forward, let's discuss how we can avoid these issues in the future. One suggestion I have is to set more realistic timelines and communicate proactively if there are any challenges that could affect deadlines. How do you feel about that approach?
Emma: That sounds like a good idea. I'll definitely work on better time management and keeping you informed if any issues arise.
Mark: That's great to hear, Emma. I want to support you in improving your performance. Let's set a goal together to improve on-time delivery by 15% over the next quarter. I'll provide you with any resources or training you need to achieve this.
Emma: I appreciate your support, Mark. I'm committed to meeting this goal.
Mark: Excellent. Is there anything else you'd like to discuss or any other areas where you feel you might need additional support?
Emma: No, I think we covered everything. I'll focus on meeting the goals we've set and improving my performance in those areas.
Mark: Perfect. Let's plan to check in regularly to review progress and adjust our approach if needed. Thank you for the productive discussion, Emma.
Emma: Thank you, Mark. I appreciate your constructive feedback and support.
Conclusion
Using the CLEAR framework empowers managers to navigate the complexities of what not to say during a performance review with professionalism and empathy. By focusing on constructive, legal, empathetic, actionable, and respectful feedback, managers can foster a positive and supportive environment that promotes employee development and growth. This structured approach ensures that performance reviews contribute positively to both individual improvement and organizational success.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
