When Leadership Decides: How to Respond and Adapt to Decisions You Don't Agree With

Introduction

As a manager, communicating decisions to your team can be a challenging task, especially when they may not align with everyone's opinions or expectations. Effective communication is crucial to ensure your team understands the reasoning behind leadership's decisions and feels valued and heard. By learning how to explain decisions to your employees, you can foster trust, build alignment, and drive success in your organization. This post will provide you with practical guidance on how to navigate this sensitive task, helping you to:

• Evaluate the importance of decisions and communicate them effectively

• Recognize and address potential concerns and questions from your team

• Foster a culture of transparency and trust

Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.

Recognizing Your Limited Context

It's crucial to acknowledge that you may not have all the information that leadership possesses. Maintain humility and avoid feeling compelled to agree or disagree with every decision. Instead, focus on understanding the context and voicing concerns when necessary.

Key Takeaways:

• Acknowledge the limits of your knowledge

• Maintain humility in the face of uncertainty

• Focus on understanding context rather than agreeing or disagreeing

Actionable Step:

Ask clarifying questions to understand the decision-making process

Example:

You're a marketing specialist, and leadership decides to launch a new product without consulting your team. You voice your disagreement, expressing concerns about the product's reception and suggesting alternative approaches. Leadership hears your concerns but decides to continue with the original plan.

You recognize that you've shared your expertise and perspective. You acknowledge that leadership has a broader understanding of the company's vision and strategy. You accept the decision and focus on making the product launch successful.

Enabling Understanding from Leadership

Good leaders provide sufficient context for decisions, enabling team members to understand the reasoning behind them. If you're frequently left in the dark, it's essential to voice your concerns and request clarity. Similarly, when making your own decisions, ensure you properly explain the context to your team.

Key Takeaways:

• Leaders should provide context for decisions

Actionable Step:

Explain context when making your own decisions

Example:

Your manager announces a new project priority without explanation, leaving you uncertain. As a team lead, you recognize the importance of understanding the decision.

You request a meeting with your manager to gain clarity. They explain that the new priority is a response to a client request that will impact revenue. They also assure you that the team's workload will be adjusted.

With this new understanding, you share the context and rationale with your team, enabling them to understand the purpose of their work. This leads to a successful project outcome.

Letting Small Things Go

Not every small mistake or oversight requires scrutiny. Pick your battles wisely, as constant criticism can be counterproductive. Focus on the bigger picture and prioritize your efforts on material and critical decisions.

Key Takeaways:

• Not every issue is worth fighting over

• Prioritize efforts on material and critical decisions

• Avoid constant criticism

Actionable Step:

Identify one area to focus on and let go of minor issues

Example:

A team member submits a report with a minor omission. Instead of dwelling on the oversight, you prioritize strategically. You recognize that the omitted detail doesn't impact the report's substance or insights.

By choosing not to nitpick, you demonstrate understanding that your team member's time and energy are better allocated to key tasks, such as analyzing findings or developing recommendations. Your decision enables your team to maintain momentum and focus on driving outcomes.

Not Dismissing Significant Issues

Some seemingly small issues may be more important than they appear. If unsure, ask others for their perspective.

Key Takeaways:

• Don't dismiss issues without considering their potential impact

• Ask for others' perspectives

• Consider the long-term effects of decisions

Actionable Step:

Ask a colleague for their perspective on a decision

Example:

Consider the potential impact on employee morale and financial planning when changing compensation timing. Before making a decision, seek input from HR colleagues, employees, and industry data to understand the effects on contracts, benefits, and market standards. By doing so, you can make an informed decision that aligns with industry norms and prioritizes employee needs.

Forcing Change on Material/Critical Issues

When faced with material or critical decisions that are wrong, it's essential to persistently advocate for change. In rare cases, refusing to go along with a critical wrong decision may be necessary.

Key Takeaways:

• Advocate for change on material/critical issues

• Be persistent in the face of resistance

• Consider refusing to go along with a critical wrong decision

Actionable Step:

Schedule a meeting with leadership to discuss concerns

Example:

You discover a critical security flaw in the company's software. Instead of staying silent, you persistently advocate for immediate action to address the issue, even if it means delaying a product launch.

Responding to Bad Leaders

Take note of leaders who consistently make poor decisions. Avoid enabling helpless attitudes or leader bashing, and instead, focus on finding solutions and improving the situation.

Key Takeaways:

• Identify poor leadership and take note

• Avoid enabling helpless attitudes

• Focus on finding solutions

Actionable Step:

Document instances of poor leadership and develop a plan to address it

Example:

You notice that a leader is consistently making decisions without input from their team. Instead of complaining, you focus on finding solutions and suggest a team meeting to discuss decision-making processes.

Owning Outcomes

Don't act helpless if you can't influence decisions. Instead, take ownership of the outcomes and find ways to work within the given framework. If you've lost faith in the company's direction, it may be time to consider a new role.

Key Takeaways:

• Take ownership of outcomes

• Find ways to work within the given framework

• Consider leaving if you've lost faith in the company's direction

Actionable Step:

Identify one area where you can take ownership and make a positive impact

Example:

You're unhappy with the company's new product direction, but instead of complaining, you take ownership of the outcome and focus on finding ways to make the product successful within the given framework. If you're unable to make a positive impact, you consider exploring new job opportunities.

Conclusion

Managers can foster a culture of transparency and trust by mastering effective communication and decision-making skills. When disagreements arise, I advocate for a "disagree but commit" approach - sharing concerns, voicing opinions, and supporting the decision. This mindset enables teams to maintain a positive relationship with leadership, even in disagreement. By embracing "disagree but commit," managers can transform obstacles into opportunities for growth and success, aligning teams towards a common goal.

Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.