5 Ways to Deal With Employees Who Questions Your Decisions
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
As a manager, navigating situations where employees question your decisions can be complex and delicate. Here’s why it’s often challenging:
Ego and Authority Dynamics: Managers may feel their authority is undermined or challenged when decisions are questioned, triggering defensive responses.
Communication Barriers: Clearly explaining the rationale behind decisions requires effective communication skills, which not all managers possess.
Time and Resource Constraints: Addressing questions takes time and effort, which can be scarce in busy work environments.
Impact on Team Dynamics: Poor handling of questioning can erode trust and morale within the team, affecting overall productivity and cohesion.
Organizational Culture: Some cultures discourage questioning authority, making it difficult to foster open dialogue and constructive feedback.
Using the Situational Leadership Framework to Navigate Questions
Dealing with employees who question your decisions requires a nuanced approach that acknowledges varying levels of readiness and autonomy among team members. The Situational Leadership framework, developed by Paul Hersey and Kenneth Blanchard, offers a structured method for adapting your leadership style based on the situation.
What is the Situational Leadership Framework
Situational Leadership is based on the premise that effective leadership varies depending on the readiness or maturity of the employees in relation to a specific task or goal. It suggests different leadership styles for different situations:
Directing: High task focus, low relationship behavior. Suitable when employees are new to a task or lack experience.
Coaching: High task focus, high relationship behavior. Appropriate when employees have some experience but still need guidance and support.
Supporting: Low task focus, high relationship behavior. Effective when employees are experienced and capable but may benefit from encouragement and involvement.
Delegating: Low task focus, low relationship behavior. Ideal when employees are highly experienced and competent, allowing them autonomy and independence.
Why is Situational Leadership Appropriate for Handling Questions
This framework is particularly suited for handling questions because it emphasizes adapting your leadership approach based on the employee's readiness to receive and process information. By tailoring your response to the individual’s developmental stage concerning the task at hand, you can foster a more supportive and constructive dialogue.
How to Use Situational Leadership When Employees Question Your Decisions
Assess Readiness: Before responding, assess the employee's readiness level regarding the decision in question. Are they new to this type of decision-making, or do they have experience?
Adapt Your Style: Based on their readiness:
Directing: Provide clear instructions and rationale for your decision. Help them understand the context and reasoning behind it.
Coaching: Engage in a dialogue. Listen actively to their concerns or questions. Offer guidance and support while encouraging their input.
Supporting: Acknowledge their perspective and encourage discussion. Be open to considering their viewpoints and exploring alternatives together.
Delegating: Trust their judgment and decision-making capabilities. Provide minimal guidance unless they seek clarification.
Build Trust: Emphasize trust and respect in all interactions. Demonstrate that questions are welcomed as opportunities for learning and improvement rather than challenges to authority.
Communicate Effectively: Use clear and concise language to explain your decisions. Avoid jargon or overly technical explanations unless necessary.
Follow Up: After addressing questions, follow up to ensure clarity and understanding. Reiterate key points if needed and reinforce the rationale behind your decision.
Sample Dialogue
Manager: Good morning, Sarah. I noticed you had some questions about the decision to move forward with the new marketing campaign. I appreciate your interest in understanding the rationale behind it. What specifically would you like to discuss?
Employee (Sarah): Good morning, John. Yes, I'm curious about why we chose to focus on social media ads instead of traditional print ads. It seems like our target demographic might respond better to print, based on our previous campaigns.
Manager: That's a great question, Sarah. Let me explain the thought process behind that decision. We analyzed recent market trends and consumer behavior data, which indicated a significant shift towards online platforms among our target audience. Social media ads provide us with more targeted reach and analytics capabilities, which we believe will maximize our campaign's impact.
Employee (Sarah): I see your point about targeting online platforms. However, I'm concerned about missing out on older demographics who still prefer print media. Have we considered a hybrid approach to cater to both segments?
Manager: That's a valid concern, Sarah. While our primary focus is on digital channels for this campaign, I agree that we shouldn't overlook the potential of print media. How do you envision integrating a hybrid strategy? I'm open to exploring your ideas.
Employee (Sarah): Maybe we could allocate a smaller portion of the budget to targeted print ads in local newspapers or magazines that are popular among older demographics. This way, we can maintain our digital focus while still reaching those who prefer traditional media.
Manager: I appreciate your suggestion, Sarah. Let's review the budget allocation and see how we can incorporate your idea into our overall strategy. It's essential to strike a balance between our digital objectives and reaching all segments effectively. Your input is valuable in ensuring we cover all bases.
Employee (Sarah): Thank you, John. I'm glad we could discuss this. I feel more confident now about the direction of the campaign.
Manager: Absolutely, Sarah. I want to encourage you to continue sharing your insights and questions. It's through these discussions that we refine our strategies and achieve better outcomes. Thank you for bringing up your concerns—it's exactly the kind of engagement that drives our team forward.
Employee (Sarah): Thank you, John. I appreciate your openness to feedback. I'm looking forward to seeing how this campaign unfolds with our combined efforts.
Conclusion
Managing employees who question your decisions requires a balanced approach that considers both the task at hand and the readiness of your team members. The Situational Leadership framework provides a valuable tool for adapting your leadership style to effectively address questions, fostering a culture of respect, trust, and collaboration within your team. By embracing questions as opportunities for dialogue and growth, managers can strengthen team dynamics and enhance overall organizational performance.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
