6 Ways to Deal With Employees Who Undermine Your Decisions
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
Managing employees who undermine your decisions poses significant challenges for managers across various industries. Here are some reasons why it can be a complex and delicate situation:
Impact on Team Cohesion: Undermining behavior can disrupt team dynamics and cohesion. It may create factions within the team, affecting morale and productivity.
Threat to Authority: Consistent undermining can undermine the manager's authority and leadership credibility. It challenges the manager's ability to effectively lead and make decisions.
Communication Challenges: Addressing undermining behavior requires clear and assertive communication. Managers must navigate these conversations sensitively to maintain professionalism and respect.
Maintaining Fairness: Balancing assertiveness in addressing undermining behavior with fairness and respect for differing opinions can be challenging.
Organizational Culture: Organizational norms and culture may influence how undermining behavior is perceived and addressed. Some cultures may tolerate more debate and dissent, while others prioritize unity and respect for authority.
Dealing With Employees Who Undermine Your Decisions Using the COIN Framework
The COIN framework—Clarity, Ownership, Integrity, and Non-negotiables—is a structured approach that managers can employ to effectively address undermining behavior while fostering a positive work environment.
What is the COIN Framework
The COIN framework provides a systematic way for managers to handle challenging situations such as undermining behavior:
Clarity: Clearly define expectations and communicate decisions transparently to ensure everyone understands the rationale behind them.
Ownership: Foster a sense of ownership among team members for their actions and decisions, emphasizing accountability and responsibility.
Integrity: Lead with integrity by upholding ethical standards, consistency, and fairness in all interactions and decisions.
Non-negotiables: Establish non-negotiable principles and boundaries regarding respectful behavior and adherence to team norms.
Why It's Appropriate for Dealing with Undermining Behavior
Structured Approach: The COIN framework provides a clear and structured approach to addressing undermining behavior, helping managers navigate sensitive situations with clarity and purpose.
Promotes Accountability: By emphasizing ownership and accountability, the framework encourages all team members, including the manager, to take responsibility for their actions and decisions.
Maintains Integrity: Integrity is crucial in handling conflicts and maintaining trust within the team. The COIN framework guides managers in making decisions that uphold ethical standards and organizational values.
Balances Firmness and Fairness: Setting non-negotiable boundaries and enforcing consequences when necessary ensures that managers maintain authority while promoting fairness and respect among team members.
Ways to Deal With Employees Who Undermine Your Decisions Using the COIN Framework
Address the Behavior Promptly:
Clarity: Clearly communicate that undermining behavior is not acceptable and can harm team cohesion and productivity.
Ownership: Encourage the employee to take ownership of their concerns by addressing them directly rather than undermining decisions.
Seek Understanding:
Clarity: Ensure the employee understands the rationale behind your decisions and the impact of their undermining behavior.
Integrity: Approach the conversation with integrity, listening actively to their concerns while maintaining the authority of your decision-making role.
Set Clear Expectations:
Clarity: Clearly define expectations for respectful communication and adherence to team decisions.
Non-negotiables: Establish non-negotiable boundaries regarding undermining behavior and the consequences of continued actions.
Provide Constructive Feedback:
Ownership: Encourage the employee to take ownership of their behavior and its impact on team dynamics.
Integrity: Provide feedback with integrity, focusing on specific instances of undermining behavior and suggesting constructive ways to address concerns.
Follow Through Consistently:
Non-negotiables: Enforce consequences for undermining behavior if it persists despite interventions, ensuring fairness and consistency in your approach.
Integrity: Lead by example in upholding organizational values and demonstrating fairness in all interactions.
Sample Dialogue
Manager (M): Hi Sarah, thanks for meeting with me. I wanted to discuss something important regarding our recent team meetings.
Employee (E): Sure, Manager. What's on your mind?
M: I've noticed a few instances where after I've made decisions in our team meetings, there have been comments or actions that seem to question or undermine those decisions.
E: Oh, I see. I didn't realize my comments came across that way. I apologize if it seemed like I was undermining you.
M: I appreciate your honesty, Sarah. It's essential for us to maintain a cohesive team environment where decisions are respected, and everyone feels valued. Can we talk about why this might be happening?
E: Of course, Manager. Sometimes, I have concerns or different perspectives, but I realize now that how I've communicated them may not have been constructive.
M: I understand. It's crucial that we foster an environment where different viewpoints are heard and valued. Here are a few ways we can address this moving forward:
Clarity: I'll ensure that decisions made in our meetings are communicated clearly, along with the rationale behind them. This clarity will help everyone understand why certain decisions are made.
Ownership: I encourage you to take ownership of your concerns and bring them up constructively during our meetings or in private discussions. This way, we can address issues proactively without undermining decisions already made.
Integrity: It's essential for us to maintain integrity in our communications and actions. Let's commit to discussing disagreements respectfully and finding solutions that benefit the team as a whole.
E: Absolutely, Manager. I appreciate the opportunity to discuss this openly. I'll make sure to communicate any concerns directly and respectfully in the future.
M: Thank you, Sarah. Your willingness to address this issue shows your commitment to our team's success. Let's continue working together to create a positive and collaborative work environment.
Conclusion
Dealing with employees who undermine your decisions requires a strategic and empathetic approach. The COIN framework equips managers with the tools to address undermining behavior effectively while maintaining team unity and fostering a positive work environment. By emphasizing clarity, ownership, integrity, and non-negotiables, managers can navigate challenging situations with confidence and ensure that decisions are respected and upheld within the team. This approach not only addresses immediate issues but also strengthens leadership credibility and promotes a culture of mutual respect and accountability within the organization.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
