How to Redirect a Blame-Shifting Employee After a Poor Performance Review

Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.

Dealing with a blame-shifting employee after a poor performance review is one of the most challenging situations a manager can face. This scenario is particularly tricky for several reasons:

1. It combines performance issues with defensive behavior.

2. Blame-shifters often have deeply ingrained habits that are difficult to change.

3. These conversations can easily become emotional and unproductive.

4. There's a risk of enabling the behavior if not handled correctly.

5. It can negatively impact team dynamics and overall morale.

6. Managers must balance empathy with firmness to achieve results.

Given these challenges, managers need a structured approach to effectively redirect blame-shifting behavior while addressing performance issues. This is where the DIER framework comes into play.

Understanding the DIER Framework

DIER is an acronym that stands for:

D - Document

I - Investigate

E - Engage

R - Redirect

This framework is particularly appropriate for handling blame-shifting employees after poor performance reviews because it:

• Provides a fact-based foundation for discussions

• Allows for a thorough understanding of the situation

• Emphasizes direct communication

• Focuses on future improvement rather than past blame

Let's explore how to implement each step of the DIER framework:

Document

Start by meticulously documenting instances of blame-shifting behavior and performance issues. This step is crucial as it provides concrete evidence to refer to during discussions.

• Record specific examples of blame-shifting, including dates and contexts.

• Note the impact of this behavior on performance, projects, and team dynamics.

• Keep a log of previous conversations or interventions related to this issue.

For example: "On July 15, during the project debrief, John attributed the missed deadline to marketing's late input, despite having received the materials on time."

Investigate

Before engaging with the employee, gather all relevant facts about the performance issues and blame-shifting behavior.

• Review project timelines, emails, and other relevant documentation.

• If appropriate, seek input from colleagues or other managers who have worked with the employee.

• Look for patterns in the blame-shifting behavior and any potential underlying causes.

This step helps you distinguish between legitimate external factors and habitual blame-shifting.

Engage

Now it's time for a direct conversation with the employee. This step is about open communication and understanding.

• Schedule a private meeting in a neutral space.

• Present the documented facts and observations without accusation.

• Listen to the employee's perspective. Use phrases like, "I'd like to understand your view on this situation."

• Pay attention to both verbal and non-verbal cues.

Remember, the goal here is to understand, not to argue or immediately correct.

Redirect

The final step is to shift the conversation towards personal responsibility and future improvement.

• Acknowledge any valid points the employee raised during the Engage step.

• Clearly explain how blame-shifting impacts performance and team dynamics.

• Set explicit expectations for future behavior and performance.

• Collaboratively develop an action plan with specific, measurable goals.

• Schedule follow-up meetings to track progress.

For example: "Moving forward, I'd like you to focus on what you can control in your projects. Let's set up weekly check-ins to discuss any challenges you're facing and how to address them proactively."

Implementing the DIER Framework

To effectively use this framework:

1. Prepare thoroughly: Gather all necessary documentation before the meeting.

2. Stay calm: Blame-shifting can be frustrating, but maintain your composure.

3. Be specific: Use concrete examples rather than generalizations.

4. Focus on behavior, not personality: Address actions, not character.

5. Be consistent: Apply this approach consistently to reinforce the message.

Remember, the goal of using the DIER framework is not just to address the immediate performance issue, but to foster a shift towards greater personal accountability.

Sample Dialogue

Manager: "John, I've noticed a pattern in our recent project debriefs where external factors are often cited for missed deadlines. For instance, in the July 15th meeting, you mentioned marketing's late input as the reason for the delay. However, our records show that marketing delivered their materials on time. Can you help me understand your perspective on this?"

Employee: "Well, yes, they did send it on time, but the quality wasn't what I expected, so I had to spend extra time refining it."

Manager: "I see. In the future, if you encounter quality issues that might impact the timeline, I'd like you to bring that up immediately so we can address it proactively. How do you think we can improve this process going forward?"

Conclusion

By using the DIER framework, managers can transform a potentially confrontational situation into an opportunity for growth and improved performance. It provides a structured way to address blame-shifting behavior while maintaining a focus on constructive solutions and personal accountability.

Remember, changing ingrained behaviors takes time and consistent effort. Be patient, stay focused on the facts, and keep the conversation oriented towards future improvement. With persistence and the right approach, you can help redirect a blame-shifting employee towards greater accountability and improved performance.

Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.