How to Support an Emotional Employee After a Poor Performance Review
Optimize team management in minutes with ManageBetter. Start your free trial now and join Uber and Microsoft in boosting performance, gathering insights, and generating reviews—all AI-powered, no writing required.
As a manager, one of the most challenging situations you may face is supporting an emotional employee after a poor performance review. This scenario is particularly tricky for several reasons:
It requires balancing empathy with professionalism.
There's a high risk of misinterpretation and escalation.
It can impact team morale and dynamics.
It often pushes managers out of their comfort zones.
The outcome can have long-lasting effects on the employee's career and the organization.
Given these challenges, managers need a structured approach to navigate this delicate situation effectively. This is where the CALM framework comes in.
Understanding the CALM Framework
CALM is an acronym that stands for:
C - Connect and Create a safe space
A - Acknowledge emotions
L - Listen actively
M - Move forward with a plan
This framework is particularly appropriate for handling emotional employees after poor performance reviews because it:
Provides a clear structure for difficult conversations
Balances emotional support with professional guidance
Focuses on both present emotions and future improvements
Encourages open communication and collaboration
Let's dive into how to implement each step of the CALM framework:
Connect and Create a safe space
Start by setting the right environment for the conversation. Schedule a private, uninterrupted meeting in a neutral location. This could be a quiet conference room or even a walk outside the office. The goal is to create an atmosphere where the employee feels comfortable expressing themselves.
Begin the conversation with a warm, supportive tone. You might say, "I know this is a difficult situation, and I want to make sure we have an open and constructive discussion about it."
Acknowledge emotions
Recognize and validate the employee's feelings without judgment. This doesn't mean you agree with their perspective, but you're showing that you understand their emotional state.
Use empathetic statements like, "I can see that you're upset about the review results," or "It's understandable to feel disappointed in this situation."
Listen actively
This step is crucial. Allow the employee to express their thoughts and feelings without interruption. Use non-verbal cues like nodding and maintaining eye contact to show you're engaged.
Ask open-ended questions to understand their perspective better. For example, "Can you tell me more about what you found most challenging?" or "How do you feel this review reflects your overall performance?"
Avoid becoming defensive or argumentative. Your goal is to understand, not to debate.
Move forward with a plan
Once the employee has expressed their feelings and you've acknowledged them, it's time to shift the focus to the future. This step is about turning the negative experience into an opportunity for growth.
Collaborate with the employee to set specific, achievable goals. Ask questions like, "What areas do you think we should focus on for improvement?" or "What support do you need to achieve these goals?"
Offer resources and support for skill development. This could include training programs, mentoring, or additional guidance from you.
Finally, schedule follow-up meetings to track progress and provide ongoing support.
Implementing the CALM Framework
Using this framework requires practice and patience. Here are some tips for effective implementation:
Prepare in advance: Review the performance issues and potential solutions before the meeting.
Stay calm: If the employee becomes highly emotional, take a deep breath and stick to the framework.
Be genuine: Your sincerity in wanting to help the employee improve will come through.
Follow up: Don't let this be a one-time conversation. Regular check-ins show your ongoing commitment to the employee's success.
Sample Dialogue
M: Hi Sarah, thanks for coming in. I've set aside an hour for us to discuss your recent performance review. I know this can be a sensitive topic, so I wanted us to have a private space to talk openly. How are you feeling about the review?
E: (visibly upset) Honestly, I'm feeling pretty terrible. I thought I was doing well, and this review came as a shock. I don't understand why my work is being criticized like this.
M: I can see that you're upset, and I understand this is difficult to hear. It's natural to feel disappointed when a review doesn't meet your expectations. Can you tell me more about what specifically surprised or concerned you in the review?
E: (voice trembling) Well, the comments about my project management skills really hurt. I've been working so hard, often staying late to meet deadlines. It feels like none of that effort was recognized.
M: I appreciate you sharing that with me. It's clear you've been putting in a lot of effort, and it's frustrating when you feel that's not being seen. Let's talk more about the project management aspect. Can you walk me through how you typically approach managing a project?
E: (calming slightly) Sure, I usually start by creating a timeline and assigning tasks. But lately, with so many projects, I've been struggling to keep everything on track. I guess I've been focusing more on just getting things done rather than managing the process effectively.
M: Thank you for that insight. It sounds like you're dealing with a heavy workload, which is impacting your ability to manage projects as effectively as you'd like. Moving forward, how do you think we could improve this situation?
E: (thoughtful) I suppose I could use some help with prioritization and maybe some tools for better project tracking. And honestly, I might need some guidance on how to communicate better when I'm feeling overwhelmed.
M: Those are excellent suggestions, Sarah. I think focusing on these areas could really help improve your project management skills. Here's what I propose: I can arrange for you to attend a project management workshop next month, and in the meantime, we can set up weekly check-ins where we review your project load and prioritization. How does that sound?
E: (nodding) That actually sounds really helpful. I appreciate you taking the time to listen and come up with a plan.
M: I'm glad you find it helpful. Remember, the goal of this review is to help you grow and improve. I believe in your potential, and I'm here to support you. Let's schedule our first weekly check-in for next Monday. Is there anything else you'd like to discuss today?
E: (more relaxed) No, I think we've covered the main points. Thank you for listening and for your support. I feel better about moving forward now.
M: You're welcome, Sarah. I'm here to help you succeed. Let's touch base again next week, and please don't hesitate to come to me if you have any concerns in the meantime.
In this dialogue, the manager:
Connected and created a safe space for discussion
Acknowledged the employee's emotions
Listened actively to understand the employee's perspective
Moved forward with a concrete plan for improvement
This approach helped de-escalate the emotional situation and turned it into a constructive conversation about future growth.
Conclusion
Remember, the goal of using the CALM framework is not just to manage a difficult conversation, but to turn a challenging situation into an opportunity for growth and improved performance.
By approaching emotional employees with compassion, active listening, and a focus on future improvement, you can navigate this tricky situation successfully. The CALM framework provides a roadmap for these difficult conversations, helping you support your employees while maintaining professional standards and driving performance improvement.
Sharpen Your Leadership Edge: Join 3,000+ executives receiving weekly, actionable insights from industry experts. Subscribe free to The Thoughtful Leader and elevate your team's performance.
